Contact us
Menu comparison: Numbers, numbers, numbers

Menu comparison: Numbers, numbers, numbers

In the article Menu: Comparison of techniques, we compared various techniques for creating extensive menus. In this article, we show the details of the measurements of the comparison.

In all screenshots, the values are shown from bottom to top. At the bottom is the initial, first call with an empty cache.

Fluid based

SQL-Queries: Fluid based
xhprof: Fluid based

Fluid based with b13/menus

SQL-Queries: Fluid based with b13/menus
xhprof: Fluid based with b13/menus

TypoScript based, classic

SQL-Queries: TypoScript based, classic
xhprof: TypoScript based, classic

TypoScript based, cached

SQL-Queries: TypoScript based, cached
xhprof: TypoScript based, cached

TypoScript based, 2 levels cached

SQL-Queries: TypoScript based, 2 levels cached
xhprof: TypoScript based, 2 levels cached

Fluid based with b13/menus (pimped)

SQL-Queries: Fluid based with b13/menus (pimped)
xhprof: Fluid based with b13/menus (pimped)

Warming - one complete crawl, please.

Using the warming extension, we crawled the entire demo website once for all variants.

$ ddev typo3 cache:flush
$ ddev typo3 warming:cachewarmup -s 1 --limit 0

Running cache warmup 2.7.1 by Elias Häußler and contributors.
Parsing sitemaps... Done
Crawling URLs... 
 984/984 [============================] 100% -- no failures

It becomes clear how different the efforts are before a page is rendered and (hopefully) cached for the first time:

| Variant                      | Crawling finished in... |
|------------------------------|-------------------------|    
| Fluid based                  |                344.293s |
| Fluid with b13/menus         |                355.652s |
| TypoScript based             |                212.376s |
| TS, cached                   |                199.757s |
| TS, 2 levels cached          |                 37.608s |
| Fluid with b13/menus, w/o VH |                 32.484s |
Show all news

TYPO3: Finding unused files in fileadmin

Do you want to delete unused or orphaned files in fileadmin or another storage location? Unfortunately, there's no direct core functionality for this. But a small command in your site package can...

Go to news

TYPO3: Editors with individual user_upload folders

Perhaps you're familiar with this client requirement? Editors should be able to add videos using the "Add media by URL" button. But the files shouldn't be located in fileadmin/user_upload/, but rather...

Go to news

TYPO3: Finding pages in mixed mode

In TYPO3, Mixed Mode refers to translated pages that contain content only partially related to the corresponding content in the main language. This is indicated in the backend by an error message. But...

Go to news

Extbase Extensions: Think extensibility with data, site and language

Today, I have a small request for the TYPO3 extension authors out there: Make sure your extensions are extensible. This will also promote the distribution of the corresponding plugins.

Go to news

SQL: Show all tables sorted by size in descending order

Lately I've been using the SQL command more often to find out which tables in the TYPO3 database are the largest. I've published the snippet once.

Go to news

TYPO3 12 with CKEditor 5: Styles in a single selection

If you set a link in the RTE in TYPO3, you may have to choose between different link classes, for example to create buttons in the frontend. What's new in TYPO3 12 is that you can select not just one...

Go to news